Look where that got them, supporting the Edition of Suck. And they lost me. Losers.
I pretty much stopped hitting the boards regularly after that, except for the occasional post at the Mos Eisley of RPG Boards, www.TheRPGSite.com. It was easy, as I was never into many other boards, and always somehow managed to avoid the big one, www.rpgnet.com. Every time I went there it looked like a the topics were controlled by cabal of asshole admins jumping on whoever got out of line. The tyranny of culture in full effect.
I started this blog I got involved with the then-new OSR blogger crowd, and found a place more to my taste.
The OSR thing has had its ups and downs and all arounds, and has grown a lot since its humble beginnings. It's had its TARGA riots, its porn interludes, and its own naval-gazing never-ending narrations on what the fuck it is in the first place.
What's grown from it though has been far more. It's a great place to meet people who are going back home, getting back to their roots, their childhoods, their "happy places" again. People who hop on a G+ game to play D&D for the first time in decades to kick some goblin ass, fathers and sons bonding over mass slaughter in the Caves of Chaos through the joys of FLAILSNAILS. Along the way we've dissected every motherfucking rule in every single edition, whether in print or not.
People noticed! Articles were written about it in obscure places! WOTC re-printed old shit and said a lot of good stuff about the old editions as they are devloping their new edition.
One thing I noticed though--the old boards, when I popped in, still kept to themselves, discussing the same crap they always did.
Check 'em out now.
ENWORLD, a former 3e haven, then a 4e devotee playground of self-delusion and denial, decided to break out older editions of D&D on separate discussion boards. They also added a sub-breakout for the OSR (though they call it the Old School Revival. Must be a British thing.)
Tonight, as I do when I'm either bored, drunk, or under the influence of Longbottom Leaf (trifecta tonight!) I checked out RPG.net. My bookmark always takes me to the board where they talk about all RPG's in general. (In four years I haven't had the uuumph to change the where the link link goes to the D20 and D&D related board.)
Castles and Crusades three times
2e and Kara-Tur
1e and clones
Against the Giants 1-2-3
Out of 34 threads on my first page.
That's like a third of Big Purple.
I've always had nothing but disdain for Big Purple Disease Ridden Cock, but if their D&D boards have like 1/3 of the articles dealing with the OSR in some way, I may have to re-evaluate.
Also, how fucking cool are we? Look at where we've permeated? We're influencing everything!
Kinda like this.